Jimmy and Jill brace for an awkward reunion after not seeing one another for a year. Meanwhile, Pags looks to Tammy to help his sister’s band find a drummer for their big concert. Stacey has issues with Jill’s new boyfriend, who happens to be married.

Stacy scores a big audition for a Broadway show, only to be hit on by the director. After his parents demand he make life changes, Mikey makes a huge decision. Artie's plans of a father-son project may be in jeopardy with Jimmy's work opportunity.

When Jimmy introduces his family to Maya, an unexpected development upends Jimmy's future. Jill celebrates her birthday with Henry, who dazzles her with a night to remember. Meanwhile, Stacey gives Luke a second chance.

Pags tries to convince Tammy to join Wildfire as the band scores some interest from record labels. Mr. Ross attempts to broker a truce between Jill and Stacey. Jimmy gets disappointing news from Maya. Mikey is determined to get back in the dating game.

When visiting the loft, Jimmy has an encounter with Jill, who has a big interview with a prominent fashion designer. Julianna gets an opportunity to work with her ex, sparking Pags' jealousy. Genie auditions a new song.

Jimmy and Jill are unsettled about the future, especially when Jill gets a new opportunity. Lizzie doesn't like Genie's ballad, causing a rift in the band, while Tammy thinks she understands the real reason for the tension. Stacey has a huge audition.