Joe teams up with a reluctant Sheriff's department to investigate a murder that hits too close to home. A mysterious survivalist named Nate Romanowski is arrested for the crime.

Joe teams up with his old friend Wacey Hedeman to search the mountains for two missing outfitters who might be the killers. Meanwhile, Nate asks Joe's wife, Marybeth, to be his lawyer.

The town comes together at the Saddlestring Deer Days Festival and Joe is treated like a hero for solving a double murder. However, Joe and Marybeth suspect the real killers may still be at large.

After Ote Keeley's bizarre funeral, Joe and Marybeth agree it's too dangerous to continue investigating the murders. They make a deal to stop, but they both struggle to stick to that deal.

After his annual "budget meeting" with Saddlestrings goat mayor, Joe investigates a grisly crime at Violet and Vivian's emu farm. Missy and McLanahan get closer.

Joe finds a key piece of the puzzle, which gets him in trouble at work. Jeannie abandons April after a deadly encounter with a killer.

Joe and Nate form an uneasy alliance as they head up the mountain in search of evidence in support of Joe's theory. Sheriff Barnum and a posse search the mountain for Nate, who is a fugitive.

Sheridan must survive a terrifying night on her own by running and hiding from her increasingly unhinged stalker. Marybeth undergoes emergency surgery as Joe struggles to protect his family.

Joe races from Marybeth's hospital bedside to rescue Sheridan, who has spent the night running and hiding from her stalker. With help from Sheridan and Nate, Joe has a final showdown with the killers.

One year after the violent attack on the Pickett family, Joe tries to pick up the pieces as he tracks a lost hunter. Marybeth searches for meaning in her legal work.

Injured and alone, Joe tries to escape the grim threat hunting him on the mountain. Marybeth grows increasingly desperate for answers and makes a choice that will affect her whole family.

An anti-hunting activist stirs up trouble in Saddlestring as Joe grapples with what really happened on Bermuda Mountain. Marybeth joins the search for a missing young woman.

Joe and Buck Lothar head to the crime scene to catch the killer. Klamath Moore causes more trouble in Saddlestring and Nate visits his past, putting his future with Cricket in jeopardy.

Joe searches for truth in the aftermath of the serial murders as Marybeth connects the dots between Klamath and the killings. Missy re-examines her relationship with McLanahan.

Joe and Marybeth try to reconnect as Joe is shut out of the murder investigation. Nate and Cricket seek answers to past secrets while on the run.

As the focus shifts to a new suspect, Joe makes the hard decision to trust an old enemy as he searches for answers in the murder investigation.

Joe and Marybeth make a shocking discovery, while Shannon strikes a risky deal with Sheriff Barnum.

In a desperate bid to set things right, Marybeth makes a decision that will change her life forever. Shannon grieves her murdered husband while on the run from the law. Joe comes face-to-face with trauma from his past when he follows Marybeth into the woods.

Joe makes an uneasy truce in his pursuit for justice. Marybeth helps arrange a long overdue reunion.